Sunday, January 13, 2008

Annoying Whinge of the Day

As mp3 (and aac) becomes the new standard for music storage in the digital era, the complaining of audiophiles about the lack of music quality gets louder and more insistent. Via Arts and Letters Daily, here's a good example of what I'm talking about. Sure, I too am disheartened when I read that recording levels are being manipulated for volume (for best results on a portable mp3 player) at the cost of quality, but the anguished moaning about how an entire generation of kids is growing up with no experience of a quality music recording is starting to annoy me.

Here's something that no one seems to be considering: Moore's Law. In ten years, our portable mp3 players will probably be able to hold every surviving audio record ever made at lossless quality and still have room for rips of all three Lord of the Rings boxed set DVDs. Fear not audiophiles, the current trend towards shite audio quality is just a passing phase, the birth pains of the digital era. In a few years you'll be able to go back to arguing over whether the kind of wire used in your headphone cables makes the music sound 'warmer'.

3 comments:

Joel said...

Hear hear!

In double blind studies, most audiophiles can't even pick the difference between 320 kbps mp3s and an original lossless recording. It's just them being precious.

The problem with compressing sound (making recordings sound louder) started with CDs and making a good impact on radio, and this generation of music just inherited it.

I do however want to eventually have more lossless music. When DJing and stretching out music that's got a low sample rate, you start to notice the sound become "choppy" if you keep an ear out for it.

Of course, my hearing is starting to get fucked from wearing headphones that try to compete with quadrophonic stacks of multi-thousand watt speakers. I really need to get some noise canceling ones I think...

Jon said...

I dunno if noise cancelling headphones will do the trick... they're more for constant buzzes or hums that don't change much. Also, they'd need to be pretty powerful to match the speaker stacks...

Chris said...

Try something like these:
http://www.shure.com/PersonalAudio/Products/Earphones/ESeries/us_pa_E2c_content
They're in ear so the lesser bass response takes some getting used to. Until you realise you can actually hear a whole range of instruments now. I'm thinking about getting castings made to block out that last few db.